BTW, I do recommend that you use the value of your card and then some.
If the gift card you order from Craigslist has person's name written within the actual card, contact the store in question to try to do an exchange. It doesn't matter how beautiful it will come out but the effort caved doing it. https://Groups.google.com/g/giftcard-mall-my-gift-info/c/lJb4jNQqwjY